Igor Presman
Pro Forma vs T12: How to Read the Numbers in a Multifamily Deal
← All insights
November 19, 2026•5 min read

Pro Forma vs T12: How to Read the Numbers in a Multifamily Deal

Short answer: a T12 is the trailing twelve months of actual income and expenses for a multifamily building. A pro forma is the seller's forecast of what the building could earn.…

Short answer: a T12 is the trailing twelve months of actual income and expenses for a multifamily building. A pro forma is the seller's forecast of what the building could earn. When I review a deal in Miami-Dade, Broward or Palm Beach, I start with the T12 because it already happened, then work forward and ask what it would really take to reach the pro forma. That applies the same way to a 4 unit building and a 200 unit property.

Every multifamily brochure has two sets of numbers, and only one of them already happened.

Sunny seaside multifamily building in Hollywood, Florida. Photo by Esteban Carriazo, Pexels

What is a T12?

A T12, short for trailing twelve months, is the actual operating statement for the last year. It shows the rent tenants really paid, the months units sat empty, and what the owner actually spent on repairs, utilities, taxes, insurance and everything else it takes to run the building.

Ask for it month by month, not just as yearly totals. Monthly numbers show whether occupancy and collections are getting better or worse, and whether a big expense was a one time event or something that keeps coming back.

What is a pro forma?

A pro forma is the seller's forecast. It usually shows every unit at full market rent, a small round vacancy number, and repairs and maintenance that look light. There is nothing dishonest about that. It is a picture of what the building could do under a certain plan.

The question is not whether the pro forma is right or wrong. The question is what has to happen to get there, and whether you are the buyer who can make it happen.

Why I start with the T12

The T12 is where the numbers start. Price, plans and expectations all build on top of it. If I start from the pro forma, I am starting from someone else's plan. If I start from the T12, I am starting from what tenants paid and what it cost to run the building last year, and I can see every step it takes to move forward from there.

What I check on the T12

Rent collected vs the rent roll

Compare the income on the T12 to the rent roll. If the rent roll shows one number and the T12 collected less, find out why. Late payers, free rent, concessions, or units that were empty part of the year all show up here. I go through how I read the rent roll itself in how I read a multifamily rent roll before making an offer.

One time expenses

A big repair in the T12 can make expenses look heavy. Ask for the invoices. Sometimes the seller is right that it will not repeat. Sometimes it is the start of a pattern, like a roof, plumbing or an older building system that keeps needing attention.

What is missing

If the owner manages the building himself, management may not show up on the T12 at all. A buyer who plans to hire a manager should add that cost back. The same goes for any work the owner does personally, like maintenance or leasing, that a new owner would have to pay for.

Taxes and insurance for the new owner

Taxes and insurance should be priced for the new owner, not copied from the seller's year. In Florida, property taxes are generally reassessed after a sale, and insurance quotes depend on the building and the buyer. Get your own numbers before you rely on the seller's.

How to check the gap to the pro forma

If the pro forma assumes higher rents, I look at three things.

  1. Which units are under market today, and by how much.
  2. When those leases end. A rent increase that depends on leases two years out is not a year one number.
  3. Whether the higher rent is realistic for that street and that unit mix, based on what similar units nearby are actually renting for, not just asking.

I also check the leases themselves. Before closing, the estoppels should confirm the rent, deposits and dates. Here is what multifamily buyers should check on tenant estoppel certificates.

Does this change for small and large buildings?

The approach is the same from 4 units to 200. What changes is the detail. On a small building, one empty unit or one big repair moves the T12 a lot, so each line matters more. On a larger property, you are more likely to see a professional manager, more line items and more history to compare. In both cases, start with what happened and work forward.

FAQ

Q: What is the difference between a pro forma and a T12?

A T12 shows the actual income and expenses for the last twelve months. A pro forma is a forecast of what the building could earn, usually assuming market rents and lower vacancy. The T12 tells you where the building is today, and the pro forma shows where a seller thinks it could go.

Q: Should I value a multifamily building on the pro forma?

I start with the T12 and treat the pro forma as a plan. If you pay for the pro forma, you are paying the seller for work you still have to do. Check what it takes to reach those numbers and when it could realistically happen.

Q: Why ask for the T12 month by month?

Monthly numbers show trends that yearly totals hide. You can see whether occupancy is improving or slipping, when large expenses hit, and whether income is steady across the year.

Q: What expenses are often missing from a T12?

Management is a common one when the owner manages the building himself. Work the owner does personally can also be missing. Taxes and insurance may also change after a sale, so price them for the new owner.

Q: Do you work with smaller multifamily buildings?

Yes. I work with multifamily buyers and sellers in Miami-Dade, Broward and Palm Beach, and I always have multifamily at different budgets, from 4 units up to 200.

If you are looking at a multifamily deal in Miami-Dade, Broward or Palm Beach, or you want to see what I have available from 4 units to 200, reach out through igorpresman.com or email sales@igorpresman.com, and we can go through the numbers together.

Igor Presman

Igor Presman

Commercial Broker · Trybal Group

Looking for your next deal?

Off-market, on-market, or ground-up — start a conversation with me today.

Work With Me
Contact Me